Two named plaintiffs brought a putative class action against AT&T Mobility Services, alleging pregnancy-related discrimination in their employment. The district court denied the plaintiffs’ motion for class certification; the 11th Circuit denied their petition for review under Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(f); and the two named plaintiffs settled with AT&T Mobility and voluntarily dismissed their…
Year: 2024
Ignore the Citizenship of Your LCC Client at Your Peril
When subject-matter jurisdiction is based on diversity, the presence of a limited liability company or a partnership on the pleadings may require a complicated and time-consuming investigation into that party’s citizenship. The Eleventh Circuit’s decision in J.C. Penney Corporation v. Oxford Mall, LLC, No. 22-12461, 2024 WL 1904569 (May 1, 2024), is an example of…
Corporate Veil May Be Pierced at Summary-Judgment Stage
W.P. Productions (“WPP”) contracted with Sam’s West, Inc., a corporation including “Sam’s Club” stores, to provide Wolfgang Puck-branded merchandise. As part of the deal, WPP agreed to pay Sam’s for featuring the Puck-branded products in Sam’s Instant Savings Booklets. WPP incurred a significant debt to Sam’s, and left over $2 million of it unpaid. In…
President to Nominate Judge Kidd to the Eleventh Circuit
President Biden has announced his intent to nominate Judge Embry J. Kidd, currently serving as a Magistrate Judge for the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida, to the Eleventh Circuit. Judge Kidd previously served as an Assistant U. S. Attorney in the Middle District and is a graduate of Emory University…
“Toxic” Lender is Dealer Required to Register Under the Exchange Act
A so-called “toxic” lender was a “dealer” required to register under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and disgorgement was an appropriate remedy for his violations, but a divided panel held that a lifetime ban from engaging in penny-stock transactions was an abuse of the district court’s discretion. S.E.C. v. Almagarby, 2024 WL 618517 (11th…
One More Time: No Standing for Injunctive Relief, No Class Settlement Approval
For the second time in less than a year, the Eleventh Circuit has vacated a district court’s approval of a class action settlement on the ground that the named plaintiffs lacked standing to seek the injunctive relief component of the settlement. In Smith v. Miorelli, 2024 WL 7700360 (11th Cir. Feb. 26, 2024), the court…
Court Identifies Factors for Analyzing Fairness of Class Settlements
The court took the opportunity to provide guidance to courts and class-action litigants on considering the fairness of a class settlement under the 2018 amendments to Rule 23(e) in Ponzio v. Pinon, 87 F.4th 487 (11th Cir. 2023). The court affirmed approval of the settlement, concluding that the district court appropriately analyzed and rejected the…
Colorado River Abstention Puts Foreclosure-Related Federal Case On Hold
Eliezer and Valeria Taveras are parties to a series of lawsuits in Florida state court, all concerning real property located in Kissimmee, Florida. In 2008, the property was the subject of an unsuccessful foreclosure action involving the Christiana Trust. Subsequently, the Taverases sought a declaration, also in Florida state court, that the mortgage on the…
Judge Charles Wilson to Take Senior Status
The Eleventh Circuit has reportedly confirmed that after nearly 25 years of service on the Court of Appeals, Judge Charles Wilson intends to take senior status upon the confirmation of a successor presumably to be nominated by President Biden later this year. Judge Wilson is the Eleventh Circuit’s most senior judge in active service, having…
Arbitration Agreement’s Non-Compliance with AAA Rules Dooms Arbitration Bid
A defendant was not aggrieved by the plaintiffs’ failure to arbitrate, and thus was not entitled to an order staying litigation and compelling arbitration, where the plaintiffs sought arbitration but the AAA refused to take their cases because of the defendant’s noncompliance with AAA rules. Bedgood v. Wyndham Vacation Resorts, Inc., 2023 WL 8722023 (11th…